Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

False Flag for InvalidArrayOffset #10743

Open
MelechMizrachi opened this issue Feb 23, 2024 · 1 comment
Open

False Flag for InvalidArrayOffset #10743

MelechMizrachi opened this issue Feb 23, 2024 · 1 comment

Comments

@MelechMizrachi
Copy link
Contributor

When working on #10738 I was able to notice this issue with string array keys being misrepresented as ints.

Fails: https://psalm.dev/r/e0a6a199fd (Note how all the keys are strings, but they are numberic)
Works: https://psalm.dev/r/4753dde5a9 (Note the 00 for the first key)

ERROR: [InvalidArrayOffset](https://psalm.dev/115) - 112:37 - Cannot access value on variable MyTest::LOOKUP using a string offset, expecting

Please close if this is expected, but this seems incorrect to me.

Copy link

I found these snippets:

https://psalm.dev/r/e0a6a199fd
<?php
                    class MyTest {
                        const LOOKUP = [
                            "0" => null,
                            "1" => null,
                            "2" => null,
                            "3" => null,
                            "4" => null,
                            "5" => null,
                            "6" => null,
                            "7" => null,
                            "8" => null,
                            "9" => null,
                            "10" => null,
                            "11" => null,
                            "12" => null,
                            "13" => null,
                            "14" => null,
                            "15" => null,
                            "16" => null,
                            "17" => null,
                            "18" => null,
                            "19" => null,
                            "20" => null,
                            "21" => null,
                            "22" => null,
                            "23" => null,
                            "24" => null,
                            "25" => null,
                            "26" => null,
                            "27" => null,
                            "28" => null,
                            "29" => null,
                            "30" => null,
                            "31" => null,
                            "32" => null,
                            "33" => null,
                            "34" => null,
                            "35" => null,
                            "36" => null,
                            "37" => null,
                            "38" => null,
                            "39" => null,
                            "40" => null,
                            "41" => null,
                            "42" => null,
                            "43" => null,
                            "44" => null,
                            "45" => null,
                            "46" => null,
                            "47" => null,
                            "48" => null,
                            "49" => null,
                            "50" => null,
                            "51" => null,
                            "52" => null,
                            "53" => null,
                            "54" => null,
                            "55" => null,
                            "56" => null,
                            "57" => null,
                            "58" => null,
                            "59" => null,
                            "60" => null,
                            "61" => null,
                            "62" => null,
                            "63" => null,
                            "64" => null,
                            "65" => null,
                            "66" => null,
                            "67" => null,
                            "68" => null,
                            "69" => null,
                            "70" => self::SUCCEED,
                            "71" => self::FAIL,
                            "72" => null,
                            "73" => null,
                            "74" => null,
                            "75" => null,
                            "76" => null,
                            "77" => null,
                            "78" => null,
                            "79" => null,
                            "80" => null,
                            "81" => null,
                            "82" => null,
                            "83" => null,
                            "84" => null,
                            "85" => null,
                            "86" => null,
                            "87" => null,
                            "88" => null,
                            "89" => null,
                            "90" => null,
                            "91" => null,
                            "92" => null,
                            "93" => null,
                            "94" => null,
                            "95" => null,
                            "96" => null,
                            "97" => null,
                            "98" => null,
                            "99" => null,
                            "100" => null,
                            "101" => null,
                        ];

                        const SUCCEED = "SUCCEED";
                        const FAIL = "FAIL";

                        public static function will_succeed(string $code) : bool {
                            return (self::LOOKUP[$code] ?? null) === self::SUCCEED;
                        }
                    }
Psalm output (using commit c488d40):

ERROR: InvalidArrayOffset - 112:37 - Cannot access value on variable MyTest::LOOKUP using a string offset, expecting 0|1|2|3|4|5|6|7|8|9|10|11|12|13|14|15|16|17|18|19|20|21|22|23|24|25|26|27|28|29|30|31|32|33|34|35|36|37|38|39|40|41|42|43|44|45|46|47|48|49|50|51|52|53|54|55|56|57|58|59|60|61|62|63|64|65|66|67|68|69|70|71|72|73|74|75|76|77|78|79|80|81|82|83|84|85|86|87|88|89|90|91|92|93|94|95|96|97|98|99|100|101

ERROR: InvalidConstantAssignmentValue - 3:31 - MyTest::LOOKUP with declared type array{0: null, 100: null, 101: null, 10: null, 11: null, 12: null, 13: null, 14: null, 15: null, 16: null, 17: null, 18: null, 19: null, 1: null, 20: null, 21: null, 22: null, 23: null, 24: null, 25: null, 26: null, 27: null, 28: null, 29: null, 2: null, 30: null, 31: null, 32: null, 33: null, 34: null, 35: null, 36: null, 37: null, 38: null, 39: null, 3: null, 40: null, 41: null, 42: null, 43: null, 44: null, 45: null, 46: null, 47: null, 48: null, 49: null, 4: null, 50: null, 51: null, 52: null, 53: null, 54: null, 55: null, 56: null, 57: null, 58: null, 59: null, 5: null, 60: null, 61: null, 62: null, 63: null, 64: null, 65: null, 66: null, 67: null, 68: null, 69: null, 6: null, 70: 'SUCCEED', 71: 'FAIL', 72: null, 73: null, 74: null, 75: null, 76: null, 77: null, 78: null, 79: null, 7: null, 80: null, 81: null, 82: null, 83: null, 84: null, 85: null, 86: null, 87: null, 88: null, 89: null, 8: null, 90: null, 91: null, 92: null, 93: null, 94: null, 95: null, 96: null, 97: null, 98: null, 99: null, 9: null} cannot be assigned type list{null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, 'SUCCEED', 'FAIL', null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, ...<null>}
https://psalm.dev/r/4753dde5a9
<?php
                    class MyTest {
                        const LOOKUP = [
                            "00" => null,
                            "1" => null,
                            "2" => null,
                            "3" => null,
                            "4" => null,
                            "5" => null,
                            "6" => null,
                            "7" => null,
                            "8" => null,
                            "9" => null,
                            "10" => null,
                            "11" => null,
                            "12" => null,
                            "13" => null,
                            "14" => null,
                            "15" => null,
                            "16" => null,
                            "17" => null,
                            "18" => null,
                            "19" => null,
                            "20" => null,
                            "21" => null,
                            "22" => null,
                            "23" => null,
                            "24" => null,
                            "25" => null,
                            "26" => null,
                            "27" => null,
                            "28" => null,
                            "29" => null,
                            "30" => null,
                            "31" => null,
                            "32" => null,
                            "33" => null,
                            "34" => null,
                            "35" => null,
                            "36" => null,
                            "37" => null,
                            "38" => null,
                            "39" => null,
                            "40" => null,
                            "41" => null,
                            "42" => null,
                            "43" => null,
                            "44" => null,
                            "45" => null,
                            "46" => null,
                            "47" => null,
                            "48" => null,
                            "49" => null,
                            "50" => null,
                            "51" => null,
                            "52" => null,
                            "53" => null,
                            "54" => null,
                            "55" => null,
                            "56" => null,
                            "57" => null,
                            "58" => null,
                            "59" => null,
                            "60" => null,
                            "61" => null,
                            "62" => null,
                            "63" => null,
                            "64" => null,
                            "65" => null,
                            "66" => null,
                            "67" => null,
                            "68" => null,
                            "69" => null,
                            "70" => self::SUCCEED,
                            "71" => self::FAIL,
                            "72" => null,
                            "73" => null,
                            "74" => null,
                            "75" => null,
                            "76" => null,
                            "77" => null,
                            "78" => null,
                            "79" => null,
                            "80" => null,
                            "81" => null,
                            "82" => null,
                            "83" => null,
                            "84" => null,
                            "85" => null,
                            "86" => null,
                            "87" => null,
                            "88" => null,
                            "89" => null,
                            "90" => null,
                            "91" => null,
                            "92" => null,
                            "93" => null,
                            "94" => null,
                            "95" => null,
                            "96" => null,
                            "97" => null,
                            "98" => null,
                            "99" => null,
                            "100" => null,
                            "101" => null,
                        ];

                        const SUCCEED = "SUCCEED";
                        const FAIL = "FAIL";

                        public static function will_succeed(string $code) : bool {
                            return (self::LOOKUP[$code] ?? null) === self::SUCCEED;
                        }
                    }
Psalm output (using commit c488d40):

ERROR: InvalidConstantAssignmentValue - 3:31 - MyTest::LOOKUP with declared type array{00: null, 100: null, 101: null, 10: null, 11: null, 12: null, 13: null, 14: null, 15: null, 16: null, 17: null, 18: null, 19: null, 1: null, 20: null, 21: null, 22: null, 23: null, 24: null, 25: null, 26: null, 27: null, 28: null, 29: null, 2: null, 30: null, 31: null, 32: null, 33: null, 34: null, 35: null, 36: null, 37: null, 38: null, 39: null, 3: null, 40: null, 41: null, 42: null, 43: null, 44: null, 45: null, 46: null, 47: null, 48: null, 49: null, 4: null, 50: null, 51: null, 52: null, 53: null, 54: null, 55: null, 56: null, 57: null, 58: null, 59: null, 5: null, 60: null, 61: null, 62: null, 63: null, 64: null, 65: null, 66: null, 67: null, 68: null, 69: null, 6: null, 70: 'SUCCEED', 71: 'FAIL', 72: null, 73: null, 74: null, 75: null, 76: null, 77: null, 78: null, 79: null, 7: null, 80: null, 81: null, 82: null, 83: null, 84: null, 85: null, 86: null, 87: null, 88: null, 89: null, 8: null, 90: null, 91: null, 92: null, 93: null, 94: null, 95: null, 96: null, 97: null, 98: null, 99: null, 9: null} cannot be assigned type array{00: null, 100: null, 10: null, 11: null, 12: null, 13: null, 14: null, 15: null, 16: null, 17: null, 18: null, 19: null, 1: null, 20: null, 21: null, 22: null, 23: null, 24: null, 25: null, 26: null, 27: null, 28: null, 29: null, 2: null, 30: null, 31: null, 32: null, 33: null, 34: null, 35: null, 36: null, 37: null, 38: null, 39: null, 3: null, 40: null, 41: null, 42: null, 43: null, 44: null, 45: null, 46: null, 47: null, 48: null, 49: null, 4: null, 50: null, 51: null, 52: null, 53: null, 54: null, 55: null, 56: null, 57: null, 58: null, 59: null, 5: null, 60: null, 61: null, 62: null, 63: null, 64: null, 65: null, 66: null, 67: null, 68: null, 69: null, 6: null, 70: 'SUCCEED', 71: 'FAIL', 72: null, 73: null, 74: null, 75: null, 76: null, 77: null, 78: null, 79: null, 7: null, 80: null, 81: null, 82: null, 83: null, 84: null, 85: null, 86: null, 87: null, 88: null, 89: null, 8: null, 90: null, 91: null, 92: null, 93: null, 94: null, 95: null, 96: null, 97: null, 98: null, 99: null, 9: null, ...<101, null>}

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant