Timeout while using vscode debugger with any program which spawns a process

[mmohdnowfal]

Environment data

• debugpy version: 1.6.6
• OS and version: Mac ventura 13.3
• Python version : 3.10.9
• Using VS Code or Visual Studio:
  VS Code
  Version: 1.77.2 (Universal)
  Commit: e344f1f539a80912a0e9357cec841f36ce97a4e2
  Date: 2023-04-06T10:12:31.126Z
  Electron: 19.1.11
  Chromium: 102.0.5005.196
  Node.js: 16.14.2
  V8: 10.2.154.26-electron.0
  OS: Darwin arm64 22.4.0
  Sandboxed: No

Actual behavior

This issue is similar to what is reported here.
But this time, it appears to be the issue is while using vscode debugger with any program which internally uses os.execv

We use a library called Unicon, for creating a connection to any remote device via ssh.
This library internally uses os.execv, which looks like has a conflict with debugpy(pyadev_monkey.py)

For every new process created using the above library, there is a delay of 5+ seconds and this delays the debugging process and affect the developer productivity time

Expected behavior

Should spawn the process wihout any delay

Steps to reproduce:

1. Install the unicon library
   pip install pyats unicon
2. Create the below data and python file

# Example
# -------
#
#   a simple pyATS testbed YAML file

devices:
    csr1000v-1:
        type: router
        os: iosxe
        credentials:
            default:
                password: foo
                username: foo
            enable:
                password: foo
        connections:
            cli:
                protocol: ssh
                ip: 168.10.1.35

4. Create a python script

from pyats.topology import loader

testbed = loader.load('my-testbed.yaml')

device = testbed.devices['csr1000v-1']

device.connect()
device.execute('show version')

More info: https://developer.cisco.com/docs/unicon/
6. Run the debug mode

[mmohdnowfal]

Adding the below workaround to the microsoft python debugpy temporarily disables the issue.
~/.vscode/extensions/ms-python.python-2023.6.0/pythonFiles/lib/python/debugpy/_vendored/pydevd/_pydev_bundle/pydev_monkey.py

Please provide a permanent solution to this

[int19h]

It's not a conflict; it's an intentional detour of execv to enable debugging of Python subprocesses.

It doesn't seem to be affecting our multiproc tests - is this specific to Unicon?

[mmohdnowfal]

It's not a conflict; it's an intentional detour of execv to enable debugging of Python subprocesses.

It doesn't seem to be affecting our multiproc tests - is this specific to Unicon?

As of now it can be reproduced with Unicon. Ideally we should not see any delay while interacting with the process

This is what I see the logs , and every thing start working normally after this delay

2023-04-13 14:09:15,085: %UNICON-INFO: +++ connection to spawn: telnet x.x.x.x 2006, id: 139895617230832 +++
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.03s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.03s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.01s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.03s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.04s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
Trying x.x.x.x...
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
Trying x.x.x.x...
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
Trying x.x.x.x...
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds
Trying x.x.x.x...
Trying x.x.x.x...
5.02s - pydevd: Sending message related to process being replaced timed-out after 5 seconds

[mmohdnowfal]

Any comments on how to resolve this

[mmohdnowfal]

Any update on this issue, many of our team members are facing this issue

[int19h]

To clarify, do you actually need subprocess debugging in your scenario? If you just want to debug the main process, setting "subProcess":false in your debug config will disable all the process creation detouring logic.

[mmohdnowfal]

Yes we use subprocess. Ours is an test framework which triggers testcases using subprocesss. And our main interest is debugging these testcases
So using "subprocess":false will not help

[sstaley-hioscar]

This has broken my debugging process and yes, I need to be able to debug a subprocess. Will try to work around for now. It would be nice to set my own timeout.

[bernardo-suez]

Any news on this? It has been a problem for me too.